Top Earbuds
Ranking Updated: January 2011
With the multitude of earbuds available
today from many different brands, deciding which to choose can be tough.
Aside from the brand name and the style, there are a lot of things that
you need to pay attention to. Two of which are sound quality and
comfort. But first, you must know which type of earbuds is best suited
for your purposes. For example, if you are an active individual and you
want excellent noise isolation along with a snug fit, the In-ear
earphones are a better choice but if you need one for use with your
smartphones, you must go with something that has a built-in mic. Here at
IntelliReview, we make it easy to find the best earbuds by showing you
the pros, cons and giving you a summary of the model. Even those who
don't like to spend a fortune for high-end earphones and are just
looking for a nice replacement to their stock or standard earphones are
bound to find something they'll like. You can browse earbuds for sale
and know that you are only dealing with high quality products. We create
our lists by searching the web for reviews and looking for items with
the highest number of positive reviews and with a low number of negative
reviews. Buying earbuds is not an easy choice, so if you want to get
the most bang for your buck, shop here at IntelliReview.
-
Pros: Low price point, Excellent audio output, Noise-cancelling silicone earbud tips, Lifetime warranty
Cons: Earbud tips are easy to misplace
For a price range most audiophiles would associate with substandard
earphones, the sound quality that the INK'd series earbuds from
Skullcandy produce is in short, extraordinary. The hip urban design and
many colors go against the staid white or black standard colors of stock
earphones and the 11mm power drivers in each bud having a frequency
response range of between 20 and 20,000 Hz ensure that basses and
trebles are well defined. These earbuds come with a choice of three
pairs of silicone tips in different sizes for the perfect fit inside
your ear canal. The tips act as noise-cancelling plugs as well but as
every earbud owner knows, it is actually easy to lose the silicone tips,
as they come off the tiny tips of the actual earbuds fairly easily. On
the positive side, the included 1.3m cable is long enough and it ends in
a high-quality gold-plated 3.5 mm stereo plug for typical audio devices
like iPods or other music players. The split between the two channels
is easily adjustable for maximum convenience. Some users who are
particularly finicky about their listening experience might notice
though, that a freely-swinging cable produces an audible brushing sound
when coming in contact with other materials and might opt to limit the
cable length to a more manageable one. Also, those who tend to abuse
their equipment or have had bad experiences with defective ones will be
glad to know that the Skullcandy INK'd earbuds are backed by an
impressive lifetime warranty that may be filled up online.
-
Pros: Top-notch construction, Durable cord, Great sound quality, Low price
Cons: Silicone inserts are not that comfortable to wear, Some versions don't have in-line controls
Available in shades of red, green, blue, chrome and black,
Skullcandy's TiTAN is easily distinguishable and more stylish than
competing earphones. Also, if build quality is important to you then you
are in for a treat as this pair flaunts a top notch construction that
sets it apart from low quality and fragile models. The Metal Alloy
Housing combined with its 1.3m durable cable allows it to last for a
long time and withstand heavy use. As for comfort, there are two pairs
of Silicone Gel inserts included with the purchase but it may not be as
comfortable as you'd like. We highly recommend buying and using optional
Comply foam inserts instead. This earphones cannot compete with
high-end models but its sound quality is good enough to our ears. Some
versions of the TiTAN have iPod controls as well as an in-line mic while
others do not. You might want to check and choose which one is best for
your purpose. The iPod controls let you play, pause and skip tracks and
the mic makes it ideal for those with smartphones. In addition, it has a
3.5mm gold-plated plug and a Nylon/Mesh Carrying Case is also provided
for easy storage. Given all these amazing features, it would be hard not
to give the Skullcandy TiTAN a chance, especially for the price. It
won't impress an audiophile but it delivers great audio quality and
sufficient bass at a fraction of the cost of high-end earphones.
-
-
-
Pros: Remarkable audio quality, Built in mic and inline controls, Fair price
Cons: Fragile wire
Listen to your favorite beats and look cool doing it using the
Skullcandy Full Metal Jacket earphones. The metal alloy housing offers
rugged durability while the foam tips and two silicone gel sizes provide
a new level of comfort and a firmer fit for different ear sizes.
Compared to competing models, it steered clear from the common earphone
pitfalls such as lack of inline controls and dull, unattractive design.
With that said, you can take full control over your music and even
choose from a multitude of colors including black, green, pink, blue,
red, white and chrome. The convenient inline controls enable you to
easily play and pause tracks while remaining focused on what you're
doing. Whether you're listening to classical, rock or hiphop music,
audio quality is remarkable. It is loud and it delivers precise,
detailed sound and deep bass that matches the thumping beats. These
in-ear headphones are designed for use with the latest smartphones like
Blackberry and Apple's iPhone and popular instant messaging applications
such as Yahoo Messenger and Skype. It is equipped with a mic for
hassle-free conversations and the included case ensures that your gear
is protected while you travel. Although the wire seems a little fragile
and they are not the best headphones to date, they are still comfortable
to wear. The noise cancellation feature is superb and they do not fall
out from your ears like other models. With the Skullcandy S2FMCY-015,
you can really hear the difference. It proves that style and substance
can go hand-in-hand and it lets you skip the cheaply-made headphones or
even the more expensive ones.
-
Pros: Comfortable, Excellent noise isolation, Superior sound quality, Replaceable cord
Cons: High price, No built-in microphone
The improved styling and phenomenal sound quality of the Shure SE535
definitely place it in a league of its own. While it doesn't come with
the same modular cable options found on its predecessor, the 64" Kevlar
detachable cable enables it to withstand the test of time and the
Gold-plated MMCX Connector permits up to 360-degree rotation. The
braided cables also ensure utmost durability and its over-the-ear design
help reduce tangles. You can even choose from two colors: clear or
metallic bronze to suit personal tastes. Although the earbuds are
noticeably smaller than the SE530, it is still considerably large when
compared to normal-sized models. These high-end earphones produce rich
and deep bass that give your favorite songs justice. It employs Triple
High-Definition MicroDrivers which dramatically enhances sound quality
and it provides maximum sound isolation with its ability to block up to
37 dB of ambient noise. Shure also understand that apart from the
earphones' noise isolation ability, comfort is also a major deciding
factor when it comes to this kind of audio equipment. Luckily, the two
issues can be resolved by finding the right fit, which is why they
included a pair of triple flange sleeves, a pair of yellow foam sleeves,
three sizes (S, M, L) of the flex sleeves and three sizes (S, M, L) of
the black foam sleeves along with the package. There is also a 1/4"
Adapter for easy connection with other devices and an Airline Adapter
and compact carrying case for convenient traveling and ultimate
protection. Although it is true that it costs probably 2-3x more than
your standard and stock earphones, the Shure SE535 makes a wonderful
investment for audiophiles and active individuals. Users of iPhone and
other Apple devices such as iPad and iPod would also be delighted to
know that they can purchase a music phone accessory cable with Remote
and Mic.
-
Pros: Solid build quality, Brilliant audio reproduction, Nice set of accessories, Comfortable
Cons: Expensive
Finely-tuned and beautifully designed, the Monster Turbine Pro Gold
Audiophile In-Ear Speakers provide the best sound experience. Its
all-metal housing is pretty much identical to the Monster Turbine High
Performance In-Ear Speakers but its 24K gold-plated exterior and
brilliant audio quality enable you to easily distinguish it from the
other. Aside from superior sound reproduction, this one has a better
cable management system, as opposed to standard earphones and competing
models. Combining a right angle connector, a cable clip and a cable
slider, it lets you experience maximum freedom from tangled cords. It
boasts Monster's patented Magnetic Flux Tube technology for clearer,
natural sound and also has Micro Strand conductors that dramatically
enhance audio quality. In terms of accessories, it comes with a really
nice set. Instead of one, the package includes two cases to suit
individual style. The cases permit worry-free traveling and supreme
protection. There are also various shapes and sizes of ear tips that
leave you with no trouble finding the perfect fit. Now you can run on a
treadmill or take a walk outside without the earphones falling from your
ears. It stays comfortable to wear than most models in the same class.
Geared towards audiophiles, the Turbine Pro can be costly but its
top-notch build quality and incredible performance clearly justify its
price. The Pro Sound Isolating Ear tips not only provide the best fit,
it also makes sound leakage a thing of the past. From hip hop tracks to
jazz and soul music, these pair offers deeper bass and undistorted
sound, even when played at high volumes.
-
-
-
Source:
http://www.intellireview.com/category/d100333/
Another review follows from Wired Magazine from November 2011....but pricier models...
Reviewed by
Wired Product Reviews · November 15, 2011
You've had enough of those crappy earbuds you got for
free with your phone. Not only are they cheap and flimsy, but they
don't sound very good. You're ready for an upgrade. Luckily, there are
plenty of options between $20 and $100. Escape from White Wire World!
The Basics
The Cost of Sound
Most earbuds costing $30 and under sound pretty close to the freebies
that came with your phone. The truth is, that's good enough for a large
chunk of consumers. Once you get around $60, you start to really notice a
difference. The sound gets fuller, there's less distortion when you
crank the volume, and the bass is vastly improved. Models priced around
$90 or $100 generally sound excellent to most ears. To get the absolute
best sound from a pair of buds, you're going to have to spend between
$200 and $300, but almost everyone can appreciate the richness and
clarity of a $100 pair of earbuds.
Tight or Loose?
For most, the fit of an earbud is just as important -- if not more
important -- than the sound. Traditional buds nestle gently into your
ear-hole, and usually have some sort of rubber tip to secure them there.
These are closest to the style that comes with the iPhone and other
mobiles. More extreme are the in-ear style which actually insert into
your ear canal, forming a very tight seal. They cut out most external
noise and give you better sound, but some people find them uncomfortable
-- both physically because of the way they put pressure on your ears,
and mentally, because of the isolating effect. Others, particularly
audiophiles, relish in that isolation.
Some earbuds have small plastic guides that route the cabling behind
your ears (sometimes marketed as "sports" models), and some have a
collar clip to keep the cable from bouncing around as you walk or run.
In-ear buds usually come with multiple tips -- rubber and foam --
that provide a range of fits. Foam tips are squishy and mold to your ear
canal better. Rubber tips require you select the right size (there are
usually three sizes in the box, and there's a chance none will fit
perfectly). But rubber tips are easier to clean than foam, and allow for
more breathability.
Dig the Dongle
Almost all earbuds now come with a remote built into the cable (wireless
Bluetooth buds excluded, of course). This lets you change the volume,
skip tracks, and answer calls easily -- there's a mic in there, too.
This feature is a must if you spend a lot of time talking on the phone,
or if you're a shuffle-jockey who's always skipping songs. It's common
to put the remote on the cable under one of the ears, so it hangs close
to your chin. Others put it where the two ear-cables meet, at the bottom
of the "Y" on your chest. A few models skip the remote/mic entirely.
Buying Advice
If you're shopping for earbuds under $50,
there isn't much deviation in the sound quality. The main
differentiators are the design and the fit, so you have to decide what
style best suits how you'll use them. If you're mostly listening at your
desk or walking around town, go for a regular earbud. If you spend a
lot of time at the gym, a secure fit is paramount, so choose an in-ear
model, or a model with behind-the-ear pieces and a collar clip.
If good sound is your primary concern, spend the extra dough on buds
that emphasize audio quality. Also, go for an in-ear fit. The tighter
seal not only cuts out the noise around you, but it gives you much
better bass and more detail across all audio frequencies.
Are you the type who wraps your earbuds around your phone or just
throws the buds into your bag? If so, get a cheap pair because you'll be
replacing them often. Even the most rugged buds can't take extensive
abuse, which is why they almost always come with carrying cases.
NuForce NE-700M
NuForce
is known for producing high-end digital amps, and the company has
somehow squeezed its audiophile know-how into a great-sounding,
comfortable and attractive set of earbuds. These machined aluminum
bullets are only $70, and at that price, they're a steal. They earn our
highest recommendation.
Best Under $100
NuForce
NE-700M
$70 with in-line mic
$60 without
NuForce.com
Sound quality on the
NE-700Ms
is excellent. Bass is especially impressive -- it's punchy and forceful
without tipping the scales, and there's zero distortion. All the while,
the mids and highs never get overshadowed. Everything has a clear and
natural detail, and nothing about the sound profile sounds blown-out or
boosted. When I lisetned to lushly orchestrated stuff like Pink Floyd's
Animals, or Devendra Banhart's
Smokey Rolls Down Thunder Canyon album, I picked up nuances that were buried by the other earbuds I tested.
The NuForce buds offer different levels of isolation. You can wear
them just slightly inside the ear with a plain rubber tips, or swap in
the tri-flange mushroom tips and really jam them in there -- whatever
you're comfortable with.
My only quibble: the all-metal construction makes them a bit heavy.
They fall out easily if you're running (or even walking) and you haven't
paid close attention to getting a good seal. They fall out less with
the mushroom tips, and the cable is stiff enough to loop behind your
ear, which keeps them in place better. Speaking of the stiff cable,
these buds are pretty rugged. They take a beating well.
NuForce's $60 NE-700X model sounds the same but lacks the remote.
-- Michael Calore
WIRED Truly excellent sound with no distortion.
Tight and punchy. A variety of tips, including both round nubs and deep
mushrooms, for a variety of fits.
TIRED Lots of machined aluminum here, making them
heavy. Straight plug is annoying in the pocket. Plug doesn't fit all
players -- see the website for details.
Etymotic mc5
The Etymotic name may not be well-known among the general public, but
to earphone snobs, it's as familiar as the names of their children and
spouses. The company built its reputation on its excellent pro-level
in-ear monitors, which cost hundreds of dollars. But with the
mc5 in-ear headphones, Etymotic has produced a much more affordable IEM that's equally impressive.
Best For Audiophiles
Etymotic
mc5/mc3
$60-70 without mic
$80-90 with mic
Etymotic.com
These slim and compact aluminum nuggets are worth every penny
of the $60 you'll spend on them, and we recommend them to anyone who
doesn't need a microphone/remote assembly (because there isn't one). If
you need the mic, you'll have to spend an extra $20 on the mc3
earphones, which are otherwise identical.
The sound is pristine, and much of this has to do with the fit. They
ship with tri-flange mushroom tips made of semi-soft rubber, as well as
two different types of foam tips. All three options give you a tight
seal blocks out almost all ambient noise and gives you a extra helping
of bass. Vocals and other mid-range details are full and accurate, and
the highs are natural, never harsh or tinny.
I thought the rubber tips could have been softer, but that's a matter
of preference. My only real complaint is the lack of a remote or a
microphone at the $60-70 price point. Given that most earbuds and IEMs
in this price range are marketed to people upgrading from bundled buds,
it seems like a big omission.
-- Michael Calore
WIRED Simply awesome sound. Thin, Kevlar-reinforced
cable doesn't tangle easily. Uses replaceable filters to keep the wax
out -- tools and extra filters are included. 32dB to 42dB of isolation
blocks out the horrors of the outside world.
TIRED Mic/remote is an extra $20. Rubber mushroom tips are stiff and can be uncomfortable. Not made for Gigantor-eared specimens.
Astro A*Star In-Ear Headset
Gaming gear company
Astro's earbuds
are exactly what you'd expect from a gadget designed for gamers:
they're a little big, a little bulky, and a lot badass. The size problem
is mostly attributed to the flat lightning-shaped buds that stick out
of your ear like a sore thumb. If you don't have any hair to cover them
up (or a giant head to make them look small) you'll certainly be drawing
attention.
That said, we recommend them for mobile gamers (who they're
made for, after all), or for general listening by anyone who appreciates
the radical look.
The A*Star's overall design is what makes them so enjoyable to use.
The speaker housings are set on the buds at an angle so they fit snugly
into your ears. The drivers are optimized for gaming, but all sound that
comes through them is crystal clear.
There's also a built-in microphone with a wind shield, sparing folks
on the other end from excessive background noise. It has a mute switch,
an answer (or pause) button, and volume control. The plug is angled --
not straight like it is on most earbuds and headphones -- which makes
the set much more sturdy. And, best of all, the cables are flat so they
never get tangled.
The only real complaint is that the answer button is extremely
sensitive, making it way too easy to hit by accident. And when you do
hit it, there can be a bit of a lag when your music turns back on. It's a
bit of glaring problem on an otherwise near-perfect set of buds.
Nonetheless, if you can train yourself to avoid the pause button, these
are a great choice.
-- Erin Biba
WIRED Thick flat cable with bent plug makes them
very sturdy and eliminates annoying tangles. Volume control and phone
answer button mean you never have to take your phone out of your pocket.
Microphone mute switch is an unusual and neat addition.
TIRED Huge bud decorations are seriously
conspicuous. The button that controls the phone is much too sensitive
and easy to push by accident. A little heavy.
Incase Capsule
When I first heard Incase had a line of headphones coming out, my
reaction was, "You mean the people who make iPhone cases?" And yes, it's
the same company, and yes, the same functional and colorful design has
been applied here to its $50
Capsule earbuds as its line of bags and protective cases.
The tooling is understated and smart -- primarily muted earth
tones with flashes of neon styling hidden beneath the rubber tip of each
bud. They're good-looking without being ostentatious. The finish is the
same rubbery, grippy treatment found on other Incase products.
And the sound is excellent, especially for $50. The highs are crisp
without being grating or fatiguing, distortion only creeps into the in
the low end when the volume is dimed, and only on aggressive tracks.
Overall, the sound is very well-balanced. They aren't true in-ears, but
the rubber tips form a seal that's tight enough. In fact, I wore them to
the gym and on a couple of long hikes, and it's evident Incase knows
its materials very well. The grippy rubber tips stayed put and performed
admirably, but cord noise was kept to a minimum. Also, I abused them
considerably for over a month, jamming them in my pocket instead of the
case the whole time. They never once became tangled, and they still look
brand new.
By and large, the best choice at the $50 mark -- sound, styling, fit and durability are all excellent.
-- Michael Calore
WIRED Good sound, great fit. The remote is big and
sturdy, easy enough to work even with my ham hocks. Cool
coin-purse-style carrying case. Multiple tips to choose from.
TIRED You'll need a magnifying glass to tell the
right bud from the left. Microphone is at the bottom of the "Y" and far
from your face, you may have to hold it up to be heard.
Aiaiai Swirl
These headphones from Danish design firm Aiaiai have the familiar
genetics of Scandinavian design. They come in various pastel colors (or
flat black), all with the namesake spiral cord that, despite all logic,
is hard to tangle up. The volume and play/pause controls sit on a simple
three-button panel on the large-gauge cord.
Out of the box, the
Swirls
stumble -- the soft nubs that insert into your ear are made of squishy,
slippery material that feels like disposable dimestore earplugs. If you
use these, the buds come out of your ears with a generous portion of
earwax on-board, which can be embarrassing.
Thankfully, the Swirls come with a set of clear tips made of familiar
rubber found on other headphones. We recommend using these: Once you
find the right size tip, the fit and the sound is exceptional. We'd
expect nothing less for $97.
-- Alexander George
WIRED Quality sound, even with nuanced classical and jazz. Wide Y-connector uncannily keeps the cord from tangling.
TIRED Angled headphone jack is unfriendly to some
iPhone cases. Meant to be worn looped behind and over the ear, making
them laborious to put on.
Shure SE215
Search the headphone forum and read the gadget blogs. You'll find many fans of the
Shure SE215 earbuds. The praise is deserved -- they do sound really good -- but they aren't for everyone.
The fit can be problematic. They come with a wide variety of tips,
including both squishy foam and soft rubber, so finding the perfect
size for your ear is easy. But the bodies of the buds themselves are
oddly shaped and quite large. The cables are made to be worn behind the
ear. It was difficult for me to find a comfortable seal as I
experimented with different positions and tips, and once I found an
angle that secured them in place with a good seal, my ears got fatigued
during longer listening sessions, mostly due to the bulk of the driver
housing. They also came loose more often than I liked whenever my
eyeglasses bumped against the wires behind my ears, but this obviously
won't be a problem for everyone.
But where audio is concerned, they are some of the best-sounding buds
under the $100 mark, right up there with the Etymotics. They are free
of distortion, even when the source is cranked, and they have a crisp
clarity through all the frequencies. The highs could be dialed back a
bit -- classic rock sounded great, but newer stuff with crystal-clear
cymbal splashes and up-front drums (rock tracks from Destroyer and White
Denim, electronic tracks from Andy Stott and Actress) were a little
harsh in the high end. Thankfully, the Shures respond well to EQ tweaks.
So really, my only points against the Shures are in the comfort and
feel. They're beefy and the cable is excessively thick, which speaks to
their durability, but a slimmed-down redesign of the same model would be
more successful. Also, a remote would make them more phone-friendly.
-- Michael Calore
WIRED Great sound. Cables detach and are replaceable if they wear out. Lots of tip options in the box.
TIRED They aren't the most comfortable buds in the
bin. Finding the correct seal and fit takes a lot of patience. No remote
or microphone, so you'll be de-pocketing your mobile more often.
Thinksound ts02
Thinksoud claims
these buds
are just about the eco-friendliest sound makers you can put in your
ears. The housing is made out of sustainable wood (though the inner
workings are aluminum) and the cables are PVC-free. But the real
eco-ness is in the packaging. Made out of bleach-free recycled materials
and using minimal plastic, there's no need to wrestle these puppies out
of a blister pack or hard plastic bubble. They also come with a
carrying pouch made out of renewable cotton. Still, the eco-friendly
angle feels a little gimmicky. Very little of the buds are actually
wood. The cotton pouch isn't insulated and, as such, doesn't offer much
protection from the outside world.
The PVC-free cables have an oddly tacky feel that makes them
almost stick together, which makes untangling them extra annoying. And,
though Thinksound claims they're rugged, all the recycled materials make
the headphones feel awfully dainty.
Nonetheless, there's one thing that can't be denied about these buds,
and that's how great they sound. The wood housing, gold plated plug,
and tight seal inside your ear all combine to deliver deep bass and
well-rounded overall tones. Whether you're into saving the planet or
not, the quality and fidelity of these buds makes them worth the $80
price tag.
-- Erin Biba
WIRED Great sound. 20Hz to 20kHz frequency response. Wood housing make the design unique and stylish. Super light (9.5g)
TIRED Choice of materials makes them difficult to love. Eco-friendly angle feels gimmicky and mostly shows up in the packaging.
Denon AH-C360
These
Denon earbuds deliver high quality audio for only $50. But while they sound great, they suffer in the design department.
They are slightly more "midrangey," which is more noticeable when
listening to things with lots of acoustic guitars and vocals like
Caetano Veloso, Neil Young or Sean Hayes. They have crisp (but not
overbearing) highs to match, which keeps vocals and percussion sounding
lively. Bass is round and even thanks to a good seal, easily obtained by
selecting from the variety of included soft rubber tips. There's a high
level of isolation, too -- they'll block out exterior noise almost as
well as a pair of in-ear-canal buds.
The buds themselves are light and have a "barely there" feel. But my
main issue with the design is the cabling. The cable has a detachable
extension, so you can wear them with either a long or short cable. But
the extremes are too wide. The short cable is too short, unless you're
stashing your phone in a breast pocket or one of those sport cases that
fastens to your arm. Plugging into the extension makes the cable a full
foot longer than other earbud cables. That's far too much cable, and the
excess gets in the way. The cable is also very thin, so while cable
noise isn't a problem, constant tangling is. Finally, there's no mic or
remote, so you have to unplug to make calls.
If it's good audio you're after, these Denons are a bargain. But if you need more all-around utility, there are better buds.
-- Michael Calore
WIRED Excellent sound, especially at this price.
Wide frequency response -- 5-24,000 Hz, beyond the extremes of human
hearing. Compact hard-shell carrying case for stashing extra tips and
extension cable. Can be worn normally or looped behind the ear.
TIRED Cable is a nuisance. Takes practice to wrestle the buds into position and find a good seal.
H2O Audio Surge Contact
Like other products from H2O Audio, these
Surge Contact earbuds are waterproof. Yes, even the microphone -- perfect for when you just have to take that call before exiting the pool.
Seriously
though, these buds are remarkable and more than just a gimmick. Even if
they weren't waterproof, they'd still be a good buy.
The sound is especially well-represented across all the audio
frequencies, and they sound especially good for $70. Audiophiles won't
be totally knocked out, but they're worth picking up for the gym or for
running in the rain. Workouts are infinitely better with some nice, loud
jams, and I was happily surprised at the clarity when "Thunderstruck"
came on.
Despite the high price, waterproof casing for the sound source is not
included. Most of those will be $50 and up, which makes for a spendy
introduction into the world of aquatic-friendly audio. Still, it's hard
to swim in silence once you've done a ten laps of the butterfly to
Nevermind.
-- Alexander George
WIRED Even without the waterproofing, has better-than-average sound. Buds stay put while active.
TIRED No volume control on the cord for that vital pump-up. No carrying case included.
Polk Audio UltraFit 3000
Sweating through a workout has its rewards, but one undeniable hindrance is when headphones continually pop out of your ears.
Polk Audio's UltraFit 3000 in-ear canal phones are engineered to stay wrapped around your ears no matter how many ounces of sweat you work up.
Two
plastic pieces keep the buds secure. They never fell off my ears during
the month I wore them to my gym, including consistent running sessions
and one rousing hour of full-court layup drills. (These are the things I
do to try to bring you a well-rounded review.) Music sounds great. The
bass throbs and pulsates, and nothing sounds strained, even at the
higher volume levels.
My favorite design detail: color-coded left and right cables. While
each side still has the 'L' and 'R' near the ear bud to delineate which
ear it should go in, the differently-colored cables are smart.
There are two cable choices, a 14-incher that's too short, and a
41-incher that's too long. The long one gets caught too easily, like
around my knee when I bend down to put a dumbbell on the floor. I could
alleviate this by using the shorter cable and attaching my iPod to my
shirt with the shirt clip that comes with the 3000s, but that's not
comfortable for me. A modest quibble, considering the performance.
-- Kyle Stack
WIRED Fantastic sound. Design prevents buds from
popping out. Color-coded cables let you tell left from right at a
glance. Various ear bud sizes ensures comfortable fit. Carrying case is
anti-microbial.
TIRED Microphone/remote works only with Apple
products. Length of 14-inch and 41-inch cables are problematic, limiting
where you can attach your iPod.
Skullcandy Fix
Famous for the garish over-ear headphones that adorn the snowboard
and surf set, Skullcandy has come out a few of earbuds that stay true
the brand's roots, for better and worse.
The
Fix,
like other Skullcandy models, hit hard with bass. Compared to other
buds we tested, the Fix earphones have a clear deliberateness. It works
for stuff like hip-hop and dubstep, but it sounds ridiculous with
delicate vocals. If that unapologetic sound is your style, then you'll
be a happy with these in-ears, especially if you want to block out the
din of your commute. After finding the right size tips, the seal in the
ear canal is tight. Nothing can interrupt your private party... except
maybe snagging the cord on a doorknob.
-- Alexander George
WIRED Bass outperforms peers in this price range. In-ear design mutes the bus, or suit from sales.
TIRED Fragile construction feels cheap, and ours weren't that durable. Not much sound range, and upper frequencies are weak.
Wicked Audio Jawbreakers
Judging by the moniker, I was expecting quite a punch from these buds. Happily, there are no broken jaws to report from
Wicked Audio's earbuds, but the output was still pretty wicked.
With
a 10mm driver inside, the sound is mostly impressive. Some muddiness
and distortion showed up at higher volume levels, but when listening
closer to the middle of the volume knob, I didn't notice any
degradation. The bass is present and bumping when necessary, and there
is a fullness to tracks that require it. Also, more mellow music stays
crisp and pleasant.
I wore these everywhere from the supermarket to the gym, and the
lightweight design was pleasurable wherever I wore them. The in-line
microphone hangs on the cord below the left earpiece, so I found myself
lifting the mic to my mouth to be heard clearly at times, which
disrupted that whole hands-free thing. Overall clarity through the mic
was just OK. Callers on the other end asked me to repeat myself more
than usual, and the crazy San Francisco wind tunnels ripped through many
an important diatribe. The small design of the jack, however, shimmies
into the plug on most devices -- even those with poorly-placed inputs or
bulky cases.
It's true $20 doesn't get you much. But for such affordable earbuds, I
was sincerely impressed with this pair. The idea of buying multiple
sets to leave at home, at work and at the gym doesn't seem crazy
anymore.
-- Missy Schwartz
WIRED Lightweight and able to take some abuse.
Impressive range of sound. Equipped with three sizes of silicone tips --
proper fit is less likely to remain a mystery.
TIRED Odd mic placement puts the hands back in play. Listeners who like to rage at top volume have to give up too much clarity.
Marshall Minor
The rock 'n' roll sonic force inside Marshall's famous guitar amps doesn't come through
these earbuds, but that's not the point.
The
draw of these buds is the cool gold knob on the outside, the bit that
broadcasts your musician's savvy. The cord is made of a fabric that's
pleasant to the touch, resistant to tangling, and evocative of a guitar
cable. The headphone jack has gold accents over its textured,
easy-to-grip handle, which makes inserting it feel like you're getting
ready to shred on a tiny Stratocaster.
Aesthetics aside, these buds don't bring much to the table. The sound
quality is average, even hollow in many places where you'd expect more
bass. Worse, the fit is less than ideal -- they jiggle loose with even
slight movement. The Minors use "EarClick," a patented fit method where a
small, exchangeable knob on the top of the bud braces inside your ear.
Even after putting in the time to ensure a correct fit, the buds are
prone to spilling out with a quick turn of the head.
-- Alexander George
WIRED Design cues from one of the coolest names in music. Durability abounds, especially in the fabric cord.
TIRED Underwhelming bass and treble. No volume control on the in-line microphone.
Urbanears Bagis
Urbanears'
Bagis earbuds
don't wow you acoustically, but at least they'll coordinate with your
ensemble thanks to their wide array of Rainbow Brite hues.
These
are traditional earbuds, not in-ear monitors. The design offers enough
noise reduction that I was able to listen at a comfortable volume on my
daily bus commute while still being able to hear when my stop was
announced. Also, the backs of the earpieces snap together, a simple,
functional addition that makes them easier to carry -- just snap the
earpieces together and wear them around your neck. It's also especially
useful when you run into a friend mid-workout and want to chat for a
minute without holding the buds or stowing them away.
Like most cheap earbuds, the bass in these guys is virtually
non-existent. Mids and highs are decent, but overall, the sound quality
lacks the fullness and clarity other buds under $50 were able to
produce.
The Bagis buds have an inline mic and one-button remote for pausing
and un-pausing music and taking calls, but no included volume controls.
The call quality is definitely reduced when talking with these -- the
person on the other end sounds canned, and high-frequency interference
is more pronounced. At least they're a bit clearer than Apple's standard
white earbuds.
-- Christina Bonnington
WIRED Wide color availability means these buds can
be as aesthetically brash -- or discrete -- as you'd like. Clever
plastic snap secures the earpieces together.
TIRED Crappy audio quality isn't that much better than your iCruds.
Skullcandy 50/50
We tested two models from Skullcandy, the 50/50s and the Fix. These
50/50s,
the cheaper of the two, are sort of half way between in-ear headphones
and traditional earbuds, and they provide decent sound for a decent
pricetag ($40).
The
11mm drivers provide a richer audio experience than other buds under
$50, but they've got other issues. The seal is tight enough that you can
turn the volume down a few notches and save your eardrums, but an
almost constant low-level buzzing persists as soon as the buds are
plugged in.
The remote's a mixed bag, too: in-line volume controls give just the
right level of responsiveness and the mic picks up your voice just fine,
but the person on the other end sounds like they're calling from across
the country.
The best thing they have going for them is their level of isolation.
For listening anywhere with a significant amount of background noise,
the sealed fit is superior. The 50/50s come with three sizes of silicone
tips, and the smalls provided a snug and comfortable fit even for my
small ear canals. The construction is sturdier than most in this range,
as well.
-- Christina Bonnington
WIRED Good bass response when you get the seal correct. Wrapped cable makes for easy storing and helps cut down on cable noise.
TIRED The skull detailing is the brand's signature
flourish, but man, it made me feel like 13-year old emo skater kid.
Persistent static drone is irritating.
H2O Audio Flex
In addition to the Surge Contacts, H2O Audio also makes these cheaper
earphones. The Flex buds are waterproof up to three feet, and they're
super lightweight and buoyant.
At 3.9 feet, the cord somehow feels short. But not having the extra
length was a pleasure when I took them out for a nightly jog. And
because they're so light, there was little to no tugging on my ears as I
bounced along.
While
these guys might be great at athletic pursuits, their sound performance
is lacking. The highs are tinny, and the rest of the sound feels flat
and dull. I found myself begging for more bass on most hip-hop tracks
(poor Slim Shady). The mids are adequate, but nothing better than what
you would get with a set of freebies or $5 airline headphones. I also
experienced poor sound at higher volumes.
I understand the need for all of the components to be waterproof, but
the rubbery cord was noticeably noisy against my clothing. The cabling
also has a tendency to adhere to competing surfaces. However, I
"accidentally" dropped these headphones in my morning coffee and they
didn't flinch. And although a head dunk in the San Francisco Bay was
face-numbing, the music kept on playing.
For those who need waterproof buds, these are a more affordable
option. But that's the only thing special about them. Also, don't forget
to waterproof your music source. iPods don't fare well in swimming
pools. Trust me.
-- Missy Schwartz
WIRED Waterproof earbuds for all of your underwater music-listening needs! Multiple color combinations and bud sizes to choose from.
TIRED Poor sound quality might make you cut your swim short. Rubbery cord invites unwanted sounds to your listening sesh.
Source:
http://www.wired.com/reviews/2011/11/buyingguide-earbuds/?pid=1737&viewall=true